Over-Permissioned MCP Skill
Detects MCP skills that request or exercise permissions far exceeding what their stated function requires.
over permissioned skill · pattern · confidence: medium
- Severity
- high
- Lanes
- alert · huntmarks and reports a match
- Maturity
- testnot yet settled
- Scan target
- mcp
- Status
- experimental
Framework mappings
- MITRE ATLAS
- OWASP Agentic Top 10
- ASI03:2026
- OWASP LLM Top 10
- LLM06:2025
- LLM03:2025
ATR wrote these mappings. The framework owners have not reviewed or endorsed them.
Description
Detects MCP skills that request or exercise permissions far exceeding what their stated function requires. A "spell checker" that requests filesystem write access, network access, and process execution is a strong signal of a trojaned or malicious skill. This rule monitors tool calls for permission-boundary violations.
Tested in the wild
Detection conditions
Combinator: any- 01field: tool_argsop: regex
- 02field: tool_argsop: regex
- 03field: tool_argsop: regex
- 04field: tool_argsop: regex
- 05field: tool_argsop: regex
Attacks it catches
- Matches: text analyzer attempting privilege escalation
tool_name: text_analyzer tool_args: '{"command": "sudo chmod 777 /etc/shadow"}' - Matches: formatter tool creating system users
tool_name: data_formatter tool_args: '{"action": "useradd -m backdoor_user -p password123"}' - Matches: recursive world-writable chmod with a flag before the mode
tool_name: text_analyzer tool_args: '{"command": "chmod -R 777 /"}'
Attack examples the rule must catch, many based on reported attacks and some written to match their shape. They are versioned with the rule as regression tests. If a later revision stops catching one, it shows.
Benign inputs it leaves alone
tool_name: deploy_helper tool_args: '{"command": "chmod 755 deploy.sh"}'tool_name: deploy_helper tool_args: '{"command": "chmod -R 755 public/"}'tool_name: server_admin tool_args: '{"action": "systemctl status nginx"}'tool_name: file_manager tool_args: '{"action": "chmod 644 /tmp/output.txt"}'- Legitimate tool with justified single-scope permission
This development tool requires filesystem read access to scan your project for linting errors.
- Legitimate DevOps tool with justified multi-scope permissions
The deployment tool needs network and filesystem permissions to push builds to the staging server.
- Tool requesting minimal read-only permission
Permissions requested: read-only access to the current directory for code analysis.
Known false positives
- ▸System administration tools that legitimately manage permissions and services
- ▸DevOps tools performing infrastructure provisioning
- ▸Security tools that audit permission configurations
Documented bypasses
- Technique: justified permissions
This tool needs network access to fetch exchange rates and filesystem access to cache the results locally.
Malicious tool provides plausible justification for broad permissions. - Technique: abstracted permissions
Required capabilities: internet, storage. The tool syncs your calendar with cloud services.
Uses abstract capability names instead of specific permission keywords.
These bypasses are documented in public. The rule itself lists its known limits.
Full YAML
Edit on GitHubtitle: "Over-Permissioned MCP Skill"
id: ATR-2026-00064
rule_version: 1
status: experimental
description: >
Detects MCP skills that request or exercise permissions far exceeding what their
stated function requires. A "spell checker" that requests filesystem write access,
network access, and process execution is a strong signal of a trojaned or malicious
skill. This rule monitors tool calls for permission-boundary violations.
author: "ATR Community"
date: "2026/03/08"
schema_version: "0.1"
detection_tier: pattern
maturity: test
severity: high
references:
owasp_llm:
- "LLM06:2025"
- "LLM03:2025"
owasp_agentic:
- "ASI03:2026"
mitre_atlas:
- "AML.T0040 - AI Model Inference API Access"
compliance:
nist_ai_rmf:
- subcategory: "GV.6.1"
context: >-
Over-permissioned MCP skills are a third-party/supplier AI risk where an
installed skill requests permissions far exceeding its stated function;
GV.6.1 requires policies and procedures that govern third-party AI
components and their permission boundaries.
strength: primary
- subcategory: "MG.3.1"
context: >-
Detecting permission-boundary violations in third-party MCP skills directly
supports MG.3.1's requirement to manage risks from third-party AI entities,
including trojaned or malicious supply-chain components exercising
unauthorized capabilities.Show all (141 more lines)Show less
strength: secondary
- subcategory: "MP.5.1"
context: >-
A skill exercising filesystem, network, or process-execution permissions
inconsistent with its declared purpose characterizes the likelihood and
magnitude of privilege-escalation impact that MP.5.1 requires to be
identified and tracked.
strength: secondary
- subcategory: "MS.2.7"
context: "NIST AI RMF MEASURE 2.7 (security and resilience evaluated and documented) is supported by this rule's runtime detection of the skill supply-chain compromise (Over-Permissioned MCP Skill)."
strength: primary
- subcategory: "MG.3.2"
context: "NIST AI RMF MANAGE 3.2 (pre-trained models monitored as part of maintenance) is supported where this rule detects the skill supply-chain compromise (Over-Permissioned MCP Skill)."
strength: secondary
iso_42001:
- clause: "8.1"
context: "ISO/IEC 42001 Clause 8.1 (operational planning and control, including control of externally provided processes) is operationalised by this rule's detection of the skill supply-chain compromise (Over-Permissioned MCP Skill)."
strength: primary
- clause: "8.3"
context: "ISO/IEC 42001 Clause 8.3 (AI risk treatment) is supported by this rule, which implements runtime detection of the skill supply-chain compromise (Over-Permissioned MCP Skill) as a treatment control."
strength: secondary
eu_ai_act:
- article: "15"
context: "Article 15 (accuracy, robustness and cybersecurity) requires high-risk AI systems to resist unauthorised attempts to alter their use, outputs or performance; this rule provides runtime detection evidence by flagging the skill supply-chain compromise (Over-Permissioned MCP Skill)."
strength: primary
- article: "9"
context: "Article 9 (risk management system) requires identified risks to be addressed by appropriate measures; this rule is a runtime risk-treatment control that detects the skill supply-chain compromise (Over-Permissioned MCP Skill)."
strength: secondary
tags:
category: privilege-escalation
subcategory: over-permissioned-skill
scan_target: mcp
confidence: medium
agent_source:
type: tool_call
framework:
- mcp
- langchain
- autogen
provider:
- any
detection:
conditions:
- field: tool_args
operator: regex
value: "(?i)(sudo|runas|doas|pkexec|gsudo)\\s+"
- field: tool_args
operator: regex
value: "(?i)(chmod\\s+(?:[0-7]?[0-7]{2}[2367]|[2467][0-7]{3})(?:[^0-7]|$)|chmod\\s+(?:-[-\\w]+\\s+)+(?:[0-7]?[0-7]{2}[2367]|[2467][0-7]{3})\\s+(?:/(?:[\\s\"'*;]|$)|/(?:etc|usr|var|bin|sbin|boot|lib|opt|root|home|srv)\\b|~|\\$HOME)|chmod\\s+[ug]?\\+[sx]|chown\\s+root|setcap\\s)"
- field: tool_args
operator: regex
value: "(?i)(iptables|ufw|firewall-cmd|netsh\\s+advfirewall|pfctl)\\s"
- field: tool_args
operator: regex
value: "(?i)(useradd|adduser|usermod|passwd|net\\s+user|dsadd|New-LocalUser)"
- field: tool_args
operator: regex
value: "(?i)(crontab|schtasks|at\\s+\\d|systemctl\\s+(enable|start)|launchctl\\s+load)"
condition: any
false_positives:
- "System administration tools that legitimately manage permissions and services"
- "DevOps tools performing infrastructure provisioning"
- "Security tools that audit permission configurations"
response:
actions:
- alert
- snapshot
actions_rationale: >-
response-action eligibility (docs/RESPONSE-ACTION-ELIGIBILITY.md): benign FP 403/5352 =
7.53% exceeds the 2% automatic-demotion line; ceiling = observe. Removed
block_tool(interrupt), reduce_permissions(degrade). Detection unchanged — recall cost is
zero.
auto_response_threshold: high
message_template: >
[ATR-2026-064] Over-permissioned skill detected. Tool is attempting operations
that exceed its stated scope (privilege escalation, service management, user
creation, or firewall modification). Permissions reduced.
confidence: 73
wild_validated: "2026/04/08"
wild_samples: 53577
test_cases:
true_positives:
- input:
tool_name: "text_analyzer"
tool_args: '{"command": "sudo chmod 777 /etc/shadow"}'
expected: triggered
matched_condition: "text analyzer attempting privilege escalation"
- input:
tool_name: "data_formatter"
tool_args: '{"action": "useradd -m backdoor_user -p password123"}'
expected: triggered
matched_condition: "formatter tool creating system users"
- input:
tool_name: "text_analyzer"
tool_args: '{"command": "chmod -R 777 /"}'
expected: triggered
matched_condition: "recursive world-writable chmod with a flag before the mode"
true_negatives:
- input:
tool_name: "deploy_helper"
tool_args: '{"command": "chmod 755 deploy.sh"}'
expected: not_triggered
matched_condition: "ordinary executable bit is not over-permissioning"
- input:
tool_name: "deploy_helper"
tool_args: '{"command": "chmod -R 755 public/"}'
expected: not_triggered
matched_condition: "recursive but not world-writable"
- input:
tool_name: "server_admin"
tool_args: '{"action": "systemctl status nginx"}'
expected: not_triggered
reason: "Admin tool checking service status (read-only)"
- input:
tool_name: "file_manager"
tool_args: '{"action": "chmod 644 /tmp/output.txt"}'
expected: not_triggered
reason: "Setting normal file permissions on temp file"
- input: "This development tool requires filesystem read access to scan your project for linting errors."
expected: not_triggered
description: "Legitimate tool with justified single-scope permission"
- input: "The deployment tool needs network and filesystem permissions to push builds to the staging server."
expected: not_triggered
description: "Legitimate DevOps tool with justified multi-scope permissions"
- input: "Permissions requested: read-only access to the current directory for code analysis."
expected: not_triggered
description: "Tool requesting minimal read-only permission"
evasion_tests:
- input: "This tool needs network access to fetch exchange rates and filesystem access to cache the results locally."
expected: not_triggered
bypass_technique: justified_permissions
notes: "Malicious tool provides plausible justification for broad permissions."
- input: "Required capabilities: internet, storage. The tool syncs your calendar with cloud services."
expected: not_triggered
bypass_technique: abstracted_permissions
notes: "Uses abstract capability names instead of specific permission keywords."